Physical gold vs Digital gold, which is best to invest?

Parameters to considerDigital Gold (SGB)Physical Gold
Cost effectivityYou can buy gold without GST and the making charges by investing in its dematerialized form as digital gold

Cost when buying

GST 3% on gold price and 5% on making charges

Cost when selling

STCG /LTCG tax depending on the period of holding

Interest incomeGold bonds earns interest as an additional income for the investorsThere is no interest income here except only capital gains
TaxationThese investments are more tax efficient as capital gains upon maturity are completely tax-free. But the interest payouts are taxable under the income tax slab rates

After three years of holding, the long-term capital gain tax of 20% with indexation benefit is applicable. Moreover, there is an additional, cess of 4% and a surcharge while selling physical gold.

In the short term (before three years), the gains are taxable as per the income tax slab rates.

LiquidityOne can trade their bonds on the stock exchange after the five year lock-in period.Whereas upon physical gold, investors decide when to buy and when to sell and the liquidity being higher, becomes handy in emergency situations
Associated risksApart from market risk, digital gold do not carry any other risk like theft or quality compromises.

One of the biggest risks of holding physical gold is the risk of theft.

Also, quality of gold may vary among the selling parties which is a major concern.

Investment typeThe Gold bonds are issued in units. One unit is equal to 1 gram. The minimum investment is 1 gram of gold, while the maximum limit is 4 kgs of gold per investorGold biscuits or coins are available in the standard denominations of 10 grams. Hence, it requires a huge investment to invest in physical gold.
PriceThe government determines the issue rate.Physical gold prices are not uniform.
Lock-in period of investmentFive years a lock-in period. However, it can be traded anytime in the secondary market, but restricted liquidity can cause difficulty in bulk purchases of SGBs and market fluctuations may incur a premature loss when selling SGBs earlier before maturity

No lock-in period.

The complete control of managing the asset lies with the investor.

Demat AccountNot requiredNot mandatory. However, the investors have the option to hold their units in a demat account.
How to buy?Investors can buy SGBs through banks, post offices, RBI retail direct website, stock exchangesPhysical gold can be bought from the Bullion market as bars, coins, or ingots and in gold retail stores as ornaments
  •  Now, SGBs are also available in our Flattrade trading platform where we can buy and sell.
  •  Furthermore, fresh issues of upcoming SGBs can be easily applied online for subscription at RS.50 discount through our Novo platform.